$BCgED$G$9!#(B
$B!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!](B
$B7z@_>J7P<}H/Bh#3#8#89f(B
$B?3::@A5a?M(B
$B!!>e5-?3::@A5a?M!J0J2$B$7$??3::@A5a$K$D$$$F!"9T@/ITI~?3::K!!J> $B;v!!$B#1!%?3::@A5a$K78$k=hJ,(B
$B#3!%?3::@A5a$NM}M3$NMW;](B
$B!J#1!KK\7o?=@A$K78$kEZCO!J0J2$B!!!!$7-'$N$H$*$j;ve8=CO$KB($7$FFCDj$5$l$F$$$k!#$^$?!"0J2<-($J$$$7-)$N2a(B
$B!J#2!KK\7oEZCO$K$D$$$F$O!"0LCV6-3&L@3N2=K!$K4p$E$/G'>Z $B!J#3!KK\7oEZCO$K78$kCsN173MQCOFCA $B!J#1!KK\7oG'Dj$N?=@A=q$KE:IU$5$l$?EZCOEy$ND4=q$KE:IU$5$l$? $B!J#2!KK\7o $B!J#3!KK\7oEZCO$,4^$^$l$k;zEy$N6h0h<+BN$N0LCV6-3&$O3NG':Q$_$G$"$k$3$H!"Ev3:(B
$B!!=hJ,D#$O!"K\7o?=@A$K$*$1$kK\7oEZCO$NFCDj$K$D$$$F!"K\7o=hJ,$NM}M3Bh#2$N#2(B
$B!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!](B
$BCgEDGn9/(B
$BFaGFKI1R;\@_6I$+$iDs=P$5$l$?6/@);HMQ?=@A$KBP$7!"#1#9#9#8G/#57n$K2-Fl8)(B
$B<}MQ0Q0w2q$,!"0lIt5Q2<:[7h$r2<$7$^$7$?!#(B
$B$=$N:N7h$KBP$7!"FaGFKI1R;\@_6I$O!"ITI~?=@A$r7z@_Bg?C$KDs=P$7$F$$$^$7$?!#(B
$B7z@_Bg?C$O!":#7n#2#0F|$^$G$K!"2-Fl8)<}MQ0Q0w2q$NH=CG$O0cK!$G$"$k$H$7!"(B
$B!V5Q2<:[7h
$B:[!!7h!!=q(B
$B!!FaGFKI1R;\@_6ID9!!!!;3!!:j!!?.G7O:(B
$B#3$N5,Dj$K4p$E$-!"$B
$B!!F|K\9q$H%"%a%j%+9g=09q$H$N4V$NAj8_6(NO5Z$S0BA4J]>c>rLsBh#6>r$K4p$E$/;\@_(B
$B5Z$S6h0hJB$S$KF|K\9q$K$*$1$k9g=09q73Bb$NCO0L$K4X$9$k6(Dj$N$B$N;HMQEy$K4X$9$kFCJLA
$B$G$7$?5Q2<$N:[7h!JJ?@.#8G/!J8"!KBh#89f!"J?@.#8G/!JL@!KBh#89f!J2E
$B#2!K!#0J2$B#2!%?3::@A5a$N$B!!K\7o=hJ,$r
$B!!@A5a?M$,
$B;HMQ$7$h$&$H$9$kEZCO$,8=CO$KB($7$FFCDj$5$l$F$$$k0J>e!"CsN173MQCOFCA
$B!W$rFCDj$G$-$J$$$?$aK!Bh#4#0>r$K0cH?$7!"K!Bh#4#7>rBh#19`$N!V$3$NK!N'$N5,Dj(B
$B$K0cH?$9$k$H$-!W$K3:Ev$9$k$H$7!"$^$?!"K\7o?=@A$K$D$$$F$OJd@5$K$J$8$^$J$$$H(B
$B$7$F!"5Q2<$N:[7h$r$7$?$N$O!"0cK!Kt$OITEv$G$"$k!#(B
$B!!!!5n$NH=Nc$N$H$*$j!"L$G'>ZCO$G$"$kEZCO$NFCDj$O2DG=$G$"$k!#(B
$B!!-!!!K\7oEZCO$r4^$`;zEy$N6h0h$H$3$l$KNY@\$7$F$$$k;zEy$H$N6h0h$H$N6-3&$O3N(B
$B!!!!Dj$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B!!-"!!K\7oEZCO$r4^$`;zEy$N6h0hFb$G!"K\7oEZCO$H$=$NNY@\CO$H$N6-3&$r=|$-$9$Y(B
$B!!!!$F$NEZCO$N6-3&$O4X78EZCO=jM-
$B!!!!JLA
$B!!-%!!>
$B!!-&!!EZCO=jM-
$B!!-'!!@A5a?M$NG'Dj$7$?K\7oEZCO$N=jM-
$B!!-(!!2-Fl8)CN;v$KBP$9$k?&L3<99TL?NaAJ>Y$K$*$1$kJ!2,9b:[FaGF;YItJ?@.#8G/#3(B
$B!!!!7n#2#5F|H=7h$O!"K\7oEZCO$HF1MM$KL$G'>ZCO$G$"$k%-%c%s%W!&%7!<%k%:Fb$NEZ(B
$B!!!!CO$K$D$$$F!">e5--!$J$$$7-%$N;v9`$K78$k;ve$G!"!VEZCO!&J*7o(B
$B!!!!D4=q$H$J$k$Y$-?^=q5Z$S$3$l$KE:IU$9$Y$-
$B!!!!!JJ!2,9b:[FaGF;YItJ?@.#8G/#37n#2#5F|H=7h!K$NE,K!$K3NDj$7$?;v
$B!!!!$H$,$G$-$k!W$H$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B!!-)!!J!2,9b:[FaGF;YIt>
$B!!!!CO$G$"$kEZCO$G$"$C$F$b;~8z
$B!!!!FCDj$NJ}$,!";~8z
$B!!!!$/!"2a5n$K#2EY$J$5$l$?;HMQ$N:[7h$N>l9g$bK\7o=hJ,$N>l9g$b$H$b$K=hJ,D#$O(B
$B!!!!8=CO$N>u67$r3NG'$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B!!!!!!$3$N$h$&$J;v>p$N2<$G!"2a5n$K#2EY$J$5$l$?;HMQ$N:[7h$N>l9g$HF1MM$KK\7o(B
$B!!!!EZCO$,FCDj$5$l$F$$$k$3$H$rA0Ds$H$7$FK\7o?=@A$r$7$?$N$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!"=h(B
$B!!!!J,D#$O!"2a5n$N:[7h$NE,H]$rH=CG$9$k8"8B$rM-$7$J$$$H$7$FK\7o?=@A$r0cK!$H(B
$B!!!!H=CG$7K\7o=hJ,$r9T$C$?$,!"(B
$B!!!!-!!!K\7oEZCO$,FCDj$5$l$F$$$k$+$I$&$+$O;v
$B!!!!!!?=@A$r$7!"(B
$B!!!!-"!!Nc$(<}MQ0Q0w2q$G$"$C$F$b9T@/5!4X$G$"$k0J>e!"9T@/$K7QB3@-$,$"$k$?$a(B
$B!!!!!!2a5n$N:[7h$NH=CG$NE,H]$rH=CG$9$k8"8B$rM-$7$J$$$H$O$$$($J$$$N$G$"$k$+(B
$B!!!!!!$i!"K\7oEZCO$,FCDj$5$l$F$J$$$H$9$k=hJ,D#$NH=CG$O$"$jF@$J$$$b$N$G$"$k!#(B
$B!!!!$K$*$1$k$=$l$H$OEZCO$N>l=j$r<($9I=8=$H$7$F$OF1$G$"$j!"$7$+$bK\7oG'Dj$N(B
$B!!!!?=@A=q$KE:IU$5$l$?
$B!!!!F@$J$$!#$7$?$,$C$F!"K\7o?=@A$K$*$$$FE:IU$5$l$?
$B!!K\7o=hJ,$O!"$=$NM}M3$K$*$$$F!"MW$9$k$K!"K\7oEZCO$,L$G'>ZCO$G$"$k$,$f$($K!"(B
$BK\7o?=@A$O!"$=$NE:IU=qN`Cf$N5-:\;v9`$G$"$kK!Bh#4#0>rBh#19`Bh#29f%$$+$i%K$^(B
$B$G$K7G$2$k;v9`$N$&$A!"EZCO$N=j:_!"COHV!"EZCO$NLL@QJB$S$KEZCO=jM-
$B$$$J$$Ey$K$h$j!"F19f$N5,Dj$K0cH?$9$k$?$a!"K!Bh#4#7>r$N5,Dj$K4p$E$-5Q2<$9$k(B
$B$H$$$&$N$G$"$k!#(B
$B!!$H$3$m$G!"CsN173MQCOFCA
$B#3#9>r$N5,Dj$K$h$k<}MQ0Q0w2q$N:[7h$N?=@A$O!"K!Bh#4#0>r$N5,Dj$K$h$k:[7h?=@A(B
$B=q!J0J2$B$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#$b$H$h$j!":[7h?=@A=q5Z$S$=$NE:IU=qN`$N5-:\;v9`$O!"$=$l$r(B
$B4p$K<}MQ0Q0w2q$,:[7h$r$J$9$N$KI,MW$J;v9`$G$"$k$+$i!"Ev3:E:IU=qN`$N$&$AF1>r(B
$BBh#19`Bh#29f$K7G$2$k=qN`$K$D$$$F$O!"F1>rBh#29`$K3:Ev$9$k>l9g$r=|$-!"$=$N5-(B
$B:\;v9`$K$h$j!"Ev3:;HMQ$,$J$5$l$kEZCO$HEZCO=jM-
$B$J$k$3$H$+$i!"DL>o$O!"EZCO$N=j:_Ey$K4X$9$k;v9`$r5-:\$9$l$PI,MW$K$7$F==J,$H(B
$B$$$($k$N$G$"$k!#(B
$B!!$7$+$7$J$,$i!"L$G'>ZCO$K$"$C$F$O!"EZCOEP5-Jm$N5-:\;v9`!"ITF0;:EP5-K!!JL@(B
$B<##3#2G/K!N'Bh#3#29f!KBh#1#7>r$NCO?^$K=`$:$k?^LL$H$7$FEP5-=j$KHw$($i$l$?5l(B
$BEZCOBfD"ImB0CO?^!J$$$o$f$k8x?^!KEy$H8=CO$H$N4V$KIT0lCW$,$"$k$3$H$,B?$/!"EZ(B
$BCO$N=j:_Ey$K4X$9$k;v9`$N$_$GEZCO$rFCDj$9$k$3$H$,9qFq$J>l9g$,$"$k$H$3$m!"$=(B
$B$N$h$&$JEZCO$rCsN173MQCOFCA
$B$K!"0LCV6-3&L@3N2=K!Bh#1#0>rBh#19`$N4X78=jM-
$B$G$"$k$+$i!"$=$N
$B:\$9$k$N$O!";HMQ$7$h$&$H$9$kEZCO$r8=$B>r$NG'Dj$K$h$jCsN173MQCOFCA
$B0hFb$K$"$k$3$H$r3NG'$9$k$?$a$G$"$k!#$f$($K!"EZCO$N=j:_Ey$K4X$9$k;v9`$N$_$G(B
$BEZCO$rFCDj$9$k$3$H$,:$Fq$J>l9g$K$*$1$k:[7h?=@A=q$NE:IU=qN`$K$O!"$`$7$m!"C1(B
$B=c$KEZCO$N=j:_Ey$K4X$9$k;v9`$r5-:\$9$k$N$G$OB-$j$:!"EZCO$N=j:_Ey$K4X$9$k;v(B
$B9`$r2DG=$J8B$j$G5-:\$7!"Kt$O$=$l$r!VITL@!W$H5-:\$7$?>e$G!";HMQ$7$h$&$H$9$k(B
$BEZCO$rJLES$NJ}K!$K$h$jFCDj$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$N$G$"$C$F!"$=$NFCDj$O!"CsN173(B
$BMQCOFCA
$B$5$l$?EZCO$N6h0h$H$N4X78$,L@$i$+$H$J$kDxEY$K!"$+$D!"8"Mx
$B$7$FL@$i$+$H$J$kDxEY$K$5$l$k$3$H$rMW$7!"$=$l$GB-$j$k$b$N$H2r$9$Y$-$G$"$k!#(B
$B!!$^$?!"K!Bh#4#0>rBh#19`Bh#29f%K$KJz$2$k;v9`$H$7$F$N;HMQ$7$h$&$H$9$kEZCO$K(B
$BBP1~$9$kEZCO=jM-
$B$FCN$k$3$H$N$G$-$J$$$b$N$G$"$l$P!"F1>rBh#29`$N5,Dj$K$h$j:[7h?=@A=q$NE:IU=q(B
$BN`$K5-:\$9$k$3$H$OMW$7$J$$$H$5$l$F$*$j!"2>$K!"<}MQ0Q0w2q$,?3M}$N7k2L$K4p$E(B
$B$-$=$l$,ITL@$G$"$k$HH=CG$9$k$J$i!"K!Bh#4#8>rBh#49`$?$@$7=q$N5,Dj$K$h$jEZCO(B
$B=jM-
$B$f$($K!"EZCO$N=j:_Ey$K4X$9$k;v9`$N$_$GEZCO$rFCDj$9$k$3$H$,:$Fq$J>l9g$K$*$1(B
$B$k:[7h?=@A=q$NE:IU=qN`$K$D$$$F$O!"KI1R;\@_6ID9$,2a<:$J$/$7$FCN$jF@$k8B$j$G(B
$BEZCO=jM-
$B!!0J>e$rF'$^$(!"K\7o?=@A5Z$SK\7oEZCO$K78$k;v
$B!!!!N`$N0lIt$H$7$FE:IU$7$F$$$k$3$H$,G'$a$i$l!"$3$l$K$h$j!"K\7oG'Dj$K$h$jCs(B
$B!!!!N173MQCOFCA
$B!!!!MQ$7$h$&$H$7$F$$$k$3$H$,L@$i$+$K$5$l$F$$$k$b$N$HG'$a$i$l$k!#(B
$B!!!!CO=jM-
$B!!!!$j!"$3$l$r$b$C$F8"Mx
$B!!!!Bh#19f$K$$$&!VEZCO$N6h0h!W$NFCDj$H$7$F$b==J,$J$b$N$HG'$a$i$l$k!#(B
$B!!!!6h0h$K4X$7$F$O!"K\7oEZCO$KNY@\$9$kEZCO$N=jM-
$B!!!!CO$N0LCV6-3&$NL@3N2=$N$?$a$NA
$B!J#3!K$K$*$$$F!VCO@R$,3NDj$7$F$$$J$$0J>e!"EZCO$NFCDj$O$"$jF@$J$$!W$H$$$$!"(B
$BJB$S$KK\7o=hJ,$NM}M3Bh#2$N#3$K$*$$$F!V$=$N>l=j$,!"EZCO$N=j:_!"COHV!"CO@Q!"(B
$BEZCO=jM-
$B$$!W5Z$S!VK\7o:[7h?=@ABP>]EZCO$O!"L$G'>Z$NEZCO$J$N$G!";HMQG'Dj$r$BI=<($HK\7o:[7h?=@A$K$h$kEZCOD4=qE:IU$N
$B#2$N#3$K$*$$$F!VL$7@Ls$NK\7o:[7hBP>]EZCO$N0LCV$dLL@QEy$NFCDj$,$G$-$J$$!W$H(B
$B$$$&$,!"K\7oEZCO$K!"@A5a?M$,7@Ls$K$h$jG$0U$K;HMQ8"86$r
$B$F$b!"$=$NEZCO$,K\7oG'Dj$K$h$jCsN173MQCOFCA
$BCG$5$l$?EZCO$N6h0hFb$G$"$C$F!"$+$D!"CsN173MQCOFCA
$B$5$l$k$b$N$G$"$l$P!";HMQ$KI,MW$J8BEY$H$$$&K!Bh#4#8>rBh#29`=jDj$NMW7o$rK~$?(B
$B$9$N$G$"$k$+$i!"K\7oEZCO$NA4It$K$D$$$F;HMQ$N:[7h$r9T$&$3$H$N>c32$K$O$J$jF@(B
$B$:!"$3$N$3$H$K$h$jK\7o?=@A$,0cK!$H$J$k$3$H$O$J$$!#(B
$B!!7k6I!"K\7o?=@A$O!"2?$iK!Bh#4#0>r$N5,Dj$K0cH?$9$k$b$N$G$O$J$/!"K\7o?=@A$r(B
$BF1>rBh#19`Bh#29f$N5,Dj$K0cH?$9$k$H$7$FK!Bh#4#7>r$N5,Dj$K4p$E$-5Q2<$7$?K\7o(B
$B=hJ,$K$O!"K!$N2rrBh#29`$N5,Dj$rE,MQ$9$kM>(B
$BCO$b$J$$$+$i!"
$B!!$h$C$F!"
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!7z!!@_!!Bg!!?C(B
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!NS!!42!!;R(B
nakada_h@jca.apc.org